Skip to content

Philosophy

A world that needs no great man

Aristotle said that if the shuttle could weave by itself, masters would need no slaves. The shuttle moves now, and people fear for their jobs. From Zhuangzi and Plato to Popper, Rawls, Kant and Arendt, one question: can ordinary people live more freely in a world that needs no great man?

We do not need a person who is always right. We need rules that can still be fixed when they are wrong.

The shuttle already weaves by itself

More than two thousand three hundred years ago, Aristotle set down a supposition in the Politics: if every tool could do its work on command, if the shuttle wove and the plectrum played the lyre by itself, master craftsmen would need no assistants and masters would need no slaves.

He meant it as an impossibility. Slavery seemed necessary to him because the shuttle did not move on its own.

Today the shuttle moves. Machines weave, algorithms write letters, robotic arms in warehouses work through the night. Yet we have not become free; instead we worry what people will live on once the machines have done the work.

That worry is strange in itself. It shows how tightly we have tied staying alive to selling our time, so tightly that better tools make us afraid. I want to trace it back: how does a tool slowly grow into a cage?

Two slopes of one mountain

In the Qiwulun, Zhuangzi writes that that side has its right and wrong, and this side has its right and wrong. Often what we argue about is not the mountain but which slope of it we are standing on.

The blind men and the elephant tell the same story. The one holding a leg says the elephant is a pillar; the one holding an ear says it is a fan. Nobody is lying, and each is right about one small piece.

Zhuangzi is easily read as saying everything is right. I do not read him that way. If two people stand in the same spot, in the same light, look at the same stone, and one calls it white and the other black, at least one of them is wrong. Admitting that every view is partial does not mean giving up on true and false; it only asks us to learn where someone is standing before deciding where they went wrong.

East, West, religion, science: these names are positions, not verdicts. What a piece of knowledge is worth depends on what it lights up and whether it survives a second look, not on which slope it came down.

Stop asking who should rule

In the Republic, Plato gave a beautiful answer: let the wisest rule, let philosophers be kings. For thousands of years people have been looking for that person.

Karl Popper thought the question itself was wrong. Asking who should rule assumes someone good enough will always turn up. He replaced it with another: how can we arrange our institutions so that bad or incompetent rulers cannot do too much damage?

A society that can only work once a good person arrives is really betting on luck. Clever people miscalculate, kind people tire, and even if this generation happens to be lucky, the next one may not be.

Laozi says that with the best rulers, the people barely know they exist; when the work is done, everyone says it happened of itself. I do not read this as doing nothing. I read it as good rules stepping back into the background, so that no one feels a single person's will pressing down on them.

Stepping back is not the same as having no rules. The less a society depends on one person, the clearer, more public and more evenly applied its rules must be. Where there is no king, the danger is that the rules become the new king, or that whoever writes them does.

The lottery of birth

John Rawls proposed a thought experiment. Suppose you had to design the rules of a society without knowing where in it you would be born: not your sex, race, nationality or family, not even how clever you would be. He called it the veil of ignorance.

Behind the veil, almost nobody would design a world where birthplace decides everything, because you yourself might be the one without a passport.

But once the veil lifts, we forget. Nationality, skin, who our parents are: none of it was earned, yet it often decides how much opportunity a person gets, and sometimes whether they are treated as a person at all.

I do not think cultures and peoples should disappear; they carry language, memory and the songs of ancestors. What I want to ask is only this: can a person keep where they come from without losing any of their rights as a human being because of it?

Who owns the shuttle

Back to Aristotle's shuttle. Once it weaves by itself, there is no less cloth. There is more.

Picture a farm where machines sow, water and harvest, and a few people now do what a hundred once did. By output, the world is richer. But the ninety-odd who lost their income cannot buy the grain it grows. The grain sits in the barn; the hunger stays at the door.

Whether there is enough cloth was never the hard part. The hard part is who the woven cloth belongs to.

We are used to handing this to the market, or to ever smarter calculation. Calculation does help: where the waste is, what is running short, which machine stands idle. But it cannot say who should get the one house that two people both need. That is a question of value, and no amount of speed gets around it. Machines may make more and more decisions for us, but the right to refuse a wrong decision cannot be handed over with them.

Price and dignity

Kant wrote that everything has either a price or a dignity. What has a price can be replaced by something else; what has dignity cannot.

We agree in words that people have dignity, but we live by price. A person must first prove they are useful to the market before they deserve to eat, to have a roof, to be respected. Losing a job means more than losing money; it is being told you are no longer worth anything.

In 1930 Keynes wrote to our grandchildren, predicting that within a century technical progress would let people work fifteen hours a week. Almost a century on, productivity has multiplied several times over, and our working hours have barely shrunk. Where did the time the machines saved go?

Hannah Arendt saw a further danger: a society of labourers without labour, people who know themselves only through their jobs and are left with emptiness once the jobs are gone. So freedom is not only being released from labour; it also means knowing what to do with the life you get back.

Time with family, a useless book, a question nobody pays you to study, or an afternoon lying down watching clouds. On a price list all of these are zero. In a single human life they may be everything.

A system that can admit it was wrong

Again and again in history, people have waited for a sage, a wise king, a saviour. Sometimes a good person really did arrive. Then they grew old, died, or changed.

I am more and more convinced that what is worth building is not a theory that is always right but something that can admit it was wrong: rules it shows openly, judgments it records, room for anyone it affects to say you got this wrong, and a willingness to actually change. A system that can keep improving after its designer makes a mistake is more reliable than any person who never makes one, because no such person exists.

I do not know how long such a world would take. Perhaps half of what I think now will turn out to be wrong. That is fine. Where it is wrong is exactly where the next step goes.

Knowledge not owned by any one culture. Power not staked on any one person. Staying alive no longer resting only on selling your time. This is not about who should rule the world. It asks whether, in a world without great men, ordinary people can live a little more freely.